GK Question

polity hard mcq

During a National Emergency, which Fundamental Rights cannot be suspended even by Presidential order under Article 359?

  1. Articles 14 and 19
  2. Articles 19 and 21
  3. Articles 20 and 21
  4. Articles 21 and 32

Answer: Articles 20 and 21

Non-suspendable rights (44th Amendment, 1978): (a) Article 20: Protection in respect of conviction for offences - (i) No ex post facto law, (ii) No double jeopardy, (iii) No self-incrimination, (b) Article 21: Protection of life and personal liberty - right to fair procedure, dignity, privacy, (c) Rationale: These core rights essential even during crisis; prevent executive excesses like arbitrary detention, torture, retrospective punishment, (d) Article 19 freedoms: Automatically suspended during Emergency on war/external aggression grounds (Article 358), but not during armed rebellion, (e) Historical context: 1975-77 Emergency saw widespread rights violations; 44th Amendment strengthened safeguards. Illustrates constitutional learning: balancing crisis response with rights protection.

Topic National Emergency - Fundamental Rights Suspension
Exam Relevance Emergency rights safeguards critical for UPSC Mains and Judiciary exams