Create a custom practice set
Pick category, difficulty, number of questions, and time limit. Start instantly with your own quiz.
Generate QuizGK Question
In Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980), the Supreme Court held that the balance between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles is part of the basic structure, meaning neither can be given absolute primacy; this balance ensures that social justice goals advance without destroying individual ______ protections.
- economic
- liberty
- administrative
- military
Answer: liberty
Minerva Mills FR-DPSP balance and basic structure: (a) Context: Challenge to 42nd Amendment provisions giving Directive Principles primacy over Fundamental Rights (Articles 14, 19), (b) Supreme Court holding: (i) Balance between Fundamental Rights (Part III) and Directive Principles (Part IV) is part of basic structure, (ii) Parliament cannot destroy this balance by giving absolute primacy to DPSP over FRs or vice versa, (iii) Both are complementary: FRs provide means (individual liberty, rights protection), DPSP provide ends (social justice, egalitarian society), (c) Liberty protection rationale: (i) Individual autonomy: FRs protect individual liberty against state excess; essential for human dignity, democratic participation, (ii) Checks and balances: Judicial review, separation of powers ensure state power exercised within constitutional limits, protecting liberty, (iii) Democratic legitimacy: Protecting individual liberty ensures diverse voices, dissent can flourish; essential for healthy democracy, (d) Applications: (i) Subsequent amendments: Must maintain FR-DPSP balance; courts can strike down amendments violating this balance, (ii) Policy formulation: State policies should advance DPSP goals while respecting FR protections (e.g., welfare schemes must respect privacy, due process), (iii) Judicial interpretation: Courts harmonize FRs, DPSP to give effect to both where possible, not as conflicting, (e) Contemporary relevance: (i) Digital governance: Balancing data protection (liberty) with welfare delivery (DPSP) through DPDP Act, 2023, (ii) Climate action: Balancing development rights (liberty) with environmental protection (DPSP) through sustainable development principles, (f) Illustrates constitutional harmony: Basic structure doctrine preserves complementary relationship between rights, directive principles; neither can be destroyed without altering constitutional identity, ensuring balanced approach to individual liberty and social justice.