GK Question

polity hard fill_blank

Article 44's Uniform Civil Code directive is often debated in context of gender justice: personal laws often discriminate against women in marriage, divorce, inheritance, and a uniform code based on constitutional values of ______, dignity, equality could advance women's rights while respecting religious freedom.

  1. secularism
  2. theocracy
  3. regionalism
  4. casteism

Answer: secularism

Article 44 UCC and gender justice: (a) Article 44 text: State shall endeavor to secure for citizens a uniform civil code throughout territory of India, (b) Gender justice rationale: (i) Discriminatory practices: Personal laws often discriminate against women in marriage (age, consent), divorce (maintenance, custody), inheritance (property rights), (ii) Constitutional values: UCC based on secularism, dignity, equality could ensure equal rights for women regardless of religion, (iii) Religious freedom: Article 25 protects religious practice; UCC reform requires balancing gender justice with religious sensitivity, consultation, (c) Implementation approaches: (i) Incremental reform: Laws like Hindu Code Bill (1950s), Special Marriage Act (1954) represent steps towards uniformity while respecting diversity, (ii) Judicial interpretation: Courts reform personal laws through rights-based interpretation (e.g., Shayara Bano striking down triple talaq), (iii) Legislative process: Comprehensive UCC requires broad consultation, consensus-building; Law Commission consultations seek public opinion, (d) Applications: (i) Women's rights: UCC could ensure equal marriage age, divorce rights, inheritance for women across religions, (ii) National integration: Common civil law could foster shared constitutional identity across religious differences, (iii) Comparative models: Goa's common family law, international examples inform Indian UCC debates, (e) Challenges: (i) Religious sensitivity: Personal laws tied to religious identity; reform requires careful consultation, consensus-building to avoid polarization, (ii) Federal dimension: Personal law reform involves Union-State coordination; diverse State contexts require flexible approach, (iii) Gender focus: Prioritizing women's rights in personal law reform could build consensus for incremental UCC, (f) Illustrates calibrated reform: Article 44 reflects transformative vision; balance between gender justice, religious freedom, federal diversity essential for realizing constitutional goal of uniform civil code through democratic, inclusive process.

Topic Article 44 - Uniform Civil Code and Gender Justice
Exam Relevance Article 44 UCC and gender justice critical for UPSC Mains and Judiciary exams