GK Question

polity hard mcq

During a National Emergency under Article 352, the executive power of States:

  1. Is completely abolished and taken over by Union
  2. Continues to exist but Union can give directions on manner of exercise for coordinated crisis response
  3. Is transferred to Governor permanently
  4. Is suspended until Emergency ceases

Answer: Continues to exist but Union can give directions on manner of exercise for coordinated crisis response

State executive during Emergency: (a) Article 353(b): During Emergency, Union executive power extends to giving directions to States on 'manner of exercise' of executive power, (b) State executive continuity: (i) State executive not abolished; Governor, Council of Ministers continue to function, (ii) Union directions relate to coordinated crisis response (defence, security, resource allocation), not general policy, (iii) Post-Emergency: State executive resumes full autonomy; Union directions cease, (c) Rationale: Ensure unified national response to existential threats while preserving State executive structure for post-crisis restoration, (d) Applications: (i) 1962, 1971 Emergencies: Union directions for defence coordination, resource mobilization, (ii) Post-Emergency: State executive autonomy restored; federal normalcy resumed, (e) Illustrates federal flexibility: Temporary enhancement of Union executive control for crisis management, reversible post-Emergency to restore State autonomy; balance between national security and federal autonomy.

Topic Article 352 - Effect on State Executive During Emergency
Exam Relevance State executive during Emergency critical for UPSC Mains and Judiciary exams