Create a custom practice set
Pick category, difficulty, number of questions, and time limit. Start instantly with your own quiz.
Generate QuizGK Question
The 2019 Amendment to the RTI Act changed the tenure and salary conditions of Information Commissioners to be prescribed by Central Government, raising concerns about executive influence on Information Commissions' independence.
- True
- False
Answer: True
RTI Amendment 2019 and independence: (a) Original RTI Act (2005): Information Commissioners had fixed tenure (5 years), salary/status equivalent to Election Commissioners/Supreme Court Judges to ensure independence, (b) 2019 Amendment changes: (i) Tenure: To be prescribed by Central Government (not fixed in statute), (ii) Salary: To be prescribed by Central Government (not equivalent to constitutional functionaries), (iii) Rationale stated: Parity with other tribunals, flexibility in administration, (c) Concerns: (i) Executive influence: Government could vary tenure/salary to pressure Commissioners, affect independence, (ii) Delayed appointments: Vacancies in Information Commissions lead to pendency of RTI appeals (lakhs pending), (iii) Weakened oversight: Less independent Commissions may be less effective in enforcing RTI, (d) Applications: (i) Appointment delays: Central/State Information Commissions face vacancies, affecting RTI enforcement, (ii) Judicial intervention: Courts direct governments to fill vacancies, protect RTI regime, (e) Illustrates accountability tension: RTI's effectiveness depends on independent Information Commissions; amendments raising independence concerns highlight balance between executive flexibility and institutional autonomy.