GK Question

polity medium fill_blank

The Supreme Court has interpreted Article 21 to require humane treatment of prisoners, including protection from torture, access to legal aid, and rehabilitation programs, recognizing that ______ is intrinsic to right to life even for those deprived of liberty.

  1. punishment
  2. dignity
  3. isolation
  4. retribution

Answer: dignity

Prison reforms and dignity: (a) Constitutional basis: Article 21 (right to life includes dignity) applies to all persons, including prisoners; deprivation of liberty does not mean deprivation of dignity, (b) Judicial directions: (i) Protection from torture: Custodial violence violates Article 21; guidelines for arrest, detention, medical examination, (ii) Legal aid: Right to free legal representation under Article 21 + Legal Services Authorities Act, (iii) Rehabilitation: Vocational training, education, counseling to facilitate reintegration, (iv) Basic amenities: Adequate food, sanitation, healthcare, ventilation in prisons, (c) Applications: (i) Undertrial reforms: Periodic review committees, expedited trial for long-detained undertrials, (ii) Women prisoners: Special provisions for pregnant women, mothers with children, (iii) Mental health: Counseling, psychiatric care for prisoners with mental illness, (d) Institutional mechanisms: (i) Prison manuals: Updated guidelines for humane treatment, (ii) Monitoring: Judicial visits, human rights commissions, civil society oversight, (e) Challenges: (i) Overcrowding: Prison population exceeds capacity, affecting dignity, health, (ii) Resources: Inadequate funding for infrastructure, staff, rehabilitation programs, (iii) Attitudinal change: Training prison staff on rights-based approach, (f) Illustrates dignity-centric constitutionalism: Article 21 interpreted to protect human worth even for those in state custody; prison reforms operationalize constitutional values of dignity, rehabilitation.

Topic Article 21 - Right to Dignity and Prison Reforms
Exam Relevance Prison reforms and dignity frequently asked in UPSC and Judiciary exams