Create a custom practice set
Pick category, difficulty, number of questions, and time limit. Start instantly with your own quiz.
Generate QuizGK Question
In Davinder Singh case (2024), the Supreme Court held that States can create sub-classifications within SC reservation only if based on ______ data showing backwardness and inadequacy of representation.
- anecdotal
- quantifiable
- political
- historical
Answer: quantifiable
Sub-classification jurisprudence (Davinder Singh, 2024): (a) Holding: States can create sub-classifications within SC/ST reservations to ensure equitable distribution among more/less backward communities, (b) Conditions: (i) Classification must be based on quantifiable data showing backwardness, (ii) Must demonstrate inadequacy of representation in particular posts/areas, (iii) Must maintain overall administrative efficiency, (iv) Must not violate Article 14 (rational classification, intelligible differentia), (c) Rationale: Addresses intra-group inequalities; ensures reservation benefits reach most marginalized within reserved categories, (d) Implementation: States must conduct empirical studies, collect data, consult stakeholders before creating sub-classifications. Illustrates calibrated affirmative action: balancing group justice with individual merit, collective disadvantage with administrative efficiency.