polity hard Fill in the Blank

In SR Bommai v. Union of India (1994), the Supreme Court emphasized that Governor's report recommending President's Rule should be based on material verified through ______ sources, not just unverified media reports or political considerations.

  1. subjective
  2. independent
  3. partisan
  4. confidential

Answer: independent

Independent verification of Governor's report: (a) Context: Challenge to President's Rule imposition based on unverified reports, political considerations, (b) Supreme Court holding: (i) Governor's report must be based on objective material verified through independent sources (e.g., Assembly proceedings, independent inquiries, not just media reports), (ii) Cannot be based on: Unverified media reports, political considerations, subjective assessments, party affiliations, (iii) Judicial review: Courts can examine whether report based on independently verified material, not political considerations, (c) Applications: (i) Rameshwar Prasad (2006): Struck down Bihar Assembly dissolution based on unverified media reports, political considerations, (ii) Recent Governor cases (2022-2024): Reiterated objective standards, independent verification requirement, (d) Rationale: (i) Democratic legitimacy: Elected State governments represent people's will; Article 356 exceptional measure, not routine political tool, (ii) Constitutional morality: Governor as constitutional functionary, not political agent, (iii) Federal balance: Protects State autonomy against arbitrary Centre overreach via gubernatorial discretion, (e) Illustrates constitutional federalism: Independent verification requirement protects State autonomy; judicial review ensures Article 356 used for genuine constitutional breakdown, not political convenience.

Topic Article 356 - Governor's Report and Independent Verification
Exam Relevance Independent verification of Governor's report critical for UPSC Mains and Judiciary exams